Unit tests are a drop cloth

4

So, here’s my software analogy of the day. I was doing some painting last night and this analogy occurred to me:

Unit tests are to refactoring     like a
Drop cloth is to painting

That is, unit tests provide a form of protection such that you can modify your code as desired with the protection provided by a good unit test suite. In painting, the drop cloth serves the same purpose – it protects your floor or furniture, allowing you to paint while protecting your stuff.

More importantly, both unit tests and drop cloths feel like more work at first but ultimately save you time by allowing you to move faster.

Comments

4 Responses to “Unit tests are a drop cloth”
  1. javakid says:

    that’s a good analogy, although I think it will be more beneficial to see the the unit tests as specs instead; and then we could draw other analogies. For example, can we picture a brick factory that is supposed to build square meter bricks measure the bricks length, width and depth by eye ? in my opinion that what we do when we don’t write the test cases first. But the test cases become specs the moment we decide write them first …

  2. Scott Bale says:

    Another analogy I like is that refactoring is a bit like eating a burrito while driving. You want to get from point A to point B without either choking or squirting hot pinto beans in your lap and distracting yourself, causing you to wreck. So taking small bites symbolizes the granularity of your unit tests – smaller bites are more palatable, depending on your choice of hot sauce (i.e. assert statements) – while obviously your setUp and tearDown methods could be represented by your car’s camshaft and Taco Bell’s sour cream gun, respectively.

  3. M Easter says:

    Nice…

    If unit tests are the dropcloth, then surely an IDE (e.g. Idea) is like a good paint sprayer when it comes to refactoring…. (assuming that one sprays inside, which may be unlikely)

Trackbacks

Check out what others are saying about this post...
  1. [...] Unit tests are a drop cloth- Well said, Alex. [...]



Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!